New National Lab Study Quantifies the Cost of Transmission for Renewable Energy

October 24, 2019

We are pleased to announce a new study conducted by Berkeley Lab entitled Improving estimates of transmission capital costs for utility-scale wind and solar projects to inform renewable energy policy, which has been accepted for publication in the journal Energy Policy. A free webinar will also be held to discuss the research on November 13th, 2019 at 10:00 AM Pacific/1:00 PM Eastern. Register here: https://cc.readytalk.com/r/5vaebzt3w9l1&eom.

The study seeks better insight on the potential costs of large-scale transmission investments associated with the development of utility-scale wind and solar by using a set of complementary analytical approaches.

Based on this analysis, several key findings emerge:

Estimating the cost of transmission is challenging. 
Transmission investments often create system-wide impacts, which are idiosyncratic and dependent on geographical context. Thus, costs for system-level assets can be difficult to attribute to any individual generation resource. Transmission often provides multiple values, such as reliability and congestion relief, in addition to connecting new generators. There is often a tradeoff between maximizing wind and solar generation while minimizing the distance to load centers, thus balancing between the cost of energy and the cost of transmission is essential. The bottom line: any generalized estimate of transmission costs is difficult to apply to individual investment decisions. 

Using many different sources of data provides better cost insight. 
To show the range of cost estimates, the study combines four complementary approaches, using (1) generator interconnection applications, (2) grid expansion studies, (3) individual transmission projects, and (4) aggregate United States transmission expenditures. Each approach has advantages and drawbacks but taken together can put bounds around average transmission costs, producing a cost range with a relatively high level of confidence.

We found that the average levelized transmission capital cost for renewables ranges from $1 to $10/MWh.
Figure 1 summarizes the levelized transmission costs results derived from the four estimation approaches. We found no large, consistent disparity in the capital cost of transmission between utility-scale solar and wind resources. In general, estimated transmission costs can range from a small to large expense in relation to the levelized cost of energy for utility-scale wind ($29–$56/MWh) and solar ($36–$46/MWh) generators. Our results suggest that average transmission capital costs can increase these direct plant-level costs by 3% to 33%.


Figure 1: Summary of levelized cost of transmission for utility-scale wind and solar integration. In this figure, we summarize the results from our four key methodological approaches to estimating the cost of transmission: (1) Interconnection study, (2) simulation method, (3) Individual projects, and (4) Aggregation. While each approach generated different cost estimates, their relative narrow range of average costs gives us confidence in the bounds. 

This study’s levelized capital cost estimates for renewable-related transmission are generally lower than prior estimates. At the same time, the study’s unit costs ($/kW) are generally in line with prior estimates, highlighting the sensitivity of the levelized results to assumptions about project lifetime, discount rate, and capacity factor. A final, but important caveat to these estimates is that they do not include transmission O&M costs. Because of the potential large share of costs due to O&M, future work should consider adding transmission O&M cost estimates to the capital cost estimates. 

For further details on these findings and others, please refer to the study which can be downloaded here. In addition, a webinar summarizing key findings will be held on November 13, 2019 at 10:00 AM Pacific/1:00 PM Eastern. Register for the free webinar here.

We appreciate the funding support of the U.S. Department of Energy for making this work possible.

 

Contacts: